i9 does this every day: production, broadcast, engineering and equipment, with one team accountable from start to finish.
- Home
- Learn
- Comparisons
- SRT or NDI: which protocol to use
SRT or NDI: which protocol to use
One was built for the internet; the other, for the building network. In most productions, the question is not which one to use, but where to use each.
SRT is the protocol for carrying video over the internet or unstable networks, between the event venue, the hub, the station and the cloud. NDI is for the local network, linking cameras, switchers and computers with low latency; the two usually work together in the same production.
| SRT | NDI | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it works | Internet and wide area networks | Local network |
| Packet loss | Recovers losses with retransmission | Designed for a lossless network |
| Latency | Configurable, from fractions of a second to a few seconds | Very low on the local network |
| Bandwidth | Uses the encoder bitrate, usually a few megabits | High for full NDI, lower for NDI HX |
| Encryption | Built in, AES | Not the focus of the protocol |
| Source discovery | Point-to-point setup, with address and port | Sources show up on the network by themselves |
| Standard | Open and free | Proprietary, free to use |
| Typical use | Contribution from remotes, sending to the cloud and to broadcasters | PTZ cameras, graphics, switchers and computers in the studio |
Choose SRT if
- Carrying the signal from the event to the station or the hub, as on a live link.
- Sending to the cloud and to streaming platforms from an encoder.
- Receiving bureaus and reporters without a dedicated link.
- Any leg that goes over the internet. See the SRT protocol.
Choose NDI if
- Linking PTZ cameras, computers and switchers in the same building.
- Podcast studios, churches and video radio.
- Bringing graphics and remote calls into the switcher without capture cards.
- Productions that need many sources with a simple installation. See PTZ cameras.
Want help with this?
How it connects.
Professional streaming: SRT, NDI and encodersSRT, NDI and encoders across the full chain.NDI (network video)The short definition of NDI.SMPTE 2110 or NDI: networked video for each caseSMPTE 2110 vs NDI, for larger facilities.Live stream bandwidth calculatorCalculate the bandwidth for your broadcast.