0 Talk to i9
  1. Home
  2. Learn
  3. Comparisons
  4. SMPTE 2110 or NDI: networked video for each case
Comparison 2 min

SMPTE 2110 or NDI: networked video for each case

Both carry video over a network, which is why people confuse them. But they were built for different problems: 2110 for the backbone of a broadcast facility, NDI for agile production on an ordinary network.

The verdict

SMPTE ST 2110 is the standard for broadcast infrastructure: uncompressed video, precise timing and scale to hundreds of signals, with a dedicated network and specialist engineering. NDI is the choice for productions, churches, corporate studios and video radio, because it runs on an ordinary network, at low cost and with simple installation.

SMPTE ST 2110NDI
CompressionUncompressed video (with optional compressed profiles)Compressed, with low latency
Bandwidth per HD signalAbout 1.5 GbpsAbout 100 to 250 Mbps for full NDI, less for NDI HX
NetworkDedicated, high capacity, with managed switchesA well configured ordinary gigabit network
TimingPrecision PTP, playing the role of SDI genlockIts own timing, less strict
AudioSeparate streams, compatible with AES67Embedded in the video stream
StandardOpen SMPTE standardProprietary technology, free to use
Deployment costHighLow
Typical useBroadcasters, central equipment rooms and large OB trucksProductions, churches, podcasts, corporate and video radio
Choose SMPTE ST 2110 if
Choose NDI if
  • Small and mid-size live productions, such as event broadcasts.
  • Churches, corporate studios and video radio.
  • PTZ cameras, graphics computers and remote calls into the switcher.
  • When the budget and the crew call for simplicity. See what NDI is.

Frequently asked questions.

Can NDI replace 2110 at a station?

At small stations, NDI can cover part of production. For the backbone of large broadcasters, 2110 remains the standard, for its precision and scale.

Can the two coexist?

Yes. Gateways convert NDI to 2110 and to SDI, and many facilities use NDI at the edges, on computers and PTZ cameras, and 2110 at the core.

What about AES67 and Dante?

They are networked audio standards. AES67 is compatible with the audio part of 2110; Dante is widely used in live audio and has an AES67-compatible mode.

Which one is easier to maintain?

NDI, because it uses an ordinary network and less configuration. 2110 needs network engineering and flow monitoring.

Where can I learn more about 2110?

In the guide what is SMPTE ST 2110, which explains the standard part by part.