i9 does this every day: production, broadcast, engineering and equipment, with one team accountable from start to finish.
- Home
- Learn
- Comparisons
- SMPTE 2110 or NDI: networked video for each case
SMPTE 2110 or NDI: networked video for each case
Both carry video over a network, which is why people confuse them. But they were built for different problems: 2110 for the backbone of a broadcast facility, NDI for agile production on an ordinary network.
SMPTE ST 2110 is the standard for broadcast infrastructure: uncompressed video, precise timing and scale to hundreds of signals, with a dedicated network and specialist engineering. NDI is the choice for productions, churches, corporate studios and video radio, because it runs on an ordinary network, at low cost and with simple installation.
| SMPTE ST 2110 | NDI | |
|---|---|---|
| Compression | Uncompressed video (with optional compressed profiles) | Compressed, with low latency |
| Bandwidth per HD signal | About 1.5 Gbps | About 100 to 250 Mbps for full NDI, less for NDI HX |
| Network | Dedicated, high capacity, with managed switches | A well configured ordinary gigabit network |
| Timing | Precision PTP, playing the role of SDI genlock | Its own timing, less strict |
| Audio | Separate streams, compatible with AES67 | Embedded in the video stream |
| Standard | Open SMPTE standard | Proprietary technology, free to use |
| Deployment cost | High | Low |
| Typical use | Broadcasters, central equipment rooms and large OB trucks | Productions, churches, podcasts, corporate and video radio |
Choose SMPTE ST 2110 if
- New broadcast facilities or major rebuilds, such as when you build a TV station.
- Facilities with hundreds of signals and 4K, with networked routing.
- When uncompressed quality is a requirement.
- Integration with large-scale broadcast equipment. See SMPTE ST 2110 IP infrastructure.
Choose NDI if
- Small and mid-size live productions, such as event broadcasts.
- Churches, corporate studios and video radio.
- PTZ cameras, graphics computers and remote calls into the switcher.
- When the budget and the crew call for simplicity. See what NDI is.
Want help with this?
How it connects.
IP infrastructure and SMPTE ST 2110 for broadcastersIP infrastructure and SMPTE ST 2110 with i9TV.What SMPTE ST 2110 isThe complete guide to SMPTE ST 2110.SDI or IP for your station: which infrastructure to chooseSDI or IP for your station.SRT or NDI: which protocol to useSRT vs NDI, for carrying video over the internet.