0 Talk to i9
  1. Home
  2. Learn
  3. Comparisons
  4. SDI or IP for your station: which…
Comparison 2 min

SDI or IP for your station: which infrastructure to choose

SDI is simple, familiar and has worked for decades. IP carries video over the network and scales better. Many stations will live with both for years, and the real question is how much of each.

The verdict

SDI is still the simplest and most economical choice for small and mid-size studios and control rooms, with a crew that already knows the technology. IP, with SMPTE ST 2110, pays off in large facilities, in 4K with many signals, in installations that will grow or change often and in broadcasters that want to link several buildings and cities.

SDIIP (SMPTE ST 2110)
Upfront costLower in small and mid-size facilitiesHigher: network switches, PTP timing and licenses
ScaleEach signal needs a cable and a router portThe network carries many signals per fiber; scales in software
4KNeeds 12G-SDI or four 3G cables per signalSame network, with more bandwidth per flow
FlexibilityChanging routes can mean new cablesRoutes change in software, with no recabling
Distance and buildingsLimited on copper; fiber with convertersNatural on a network, between rooms, buildings and cities
Crew knowledgeWidely masteredNeeds network and broadcast engineering together
TroubleshootingDirect: cable, connector, deviceNeeds network tools and flow monitoring
Investment lifespanMature technology, stable marketThe path where the market is heading
Choose SDI if
  • Small and mid-size studios and control rooms, such as a regional TV studio.
  • A technical crew without network engineering experience, with a familiar SDI routing matrix.
  • Projects with a tight budget and a short timeline.
  • Expansions of an existing SDI system that works well. See what SDI is.
Choose IP (SMPTE ST 2110) if
  • Large broadcasters, with many studios and signals.
  • 4K productions with dozens of sources.
  • Installations that will grow or change often, such as a new station.
  • Links between buildings, cities and remote production. See what SMPTE ST 2110 is.

Frequently asked questions.

Is SDI going away?

Not in the short term. SDI is still in production, in new equipment and in thousands of installations. The trend is to coexist with IP, with converters at the edges.

Can you mix SDI and IP?

Yes, and it is the most common setup. Gateways convert SDI signals to IP and back, so you can migrate in stages.

What is 12G-SDI?

It is the version of SDI that carries a 4K signal on a single cable. The glossary explains it.

Is IP the same as NDI?

No. NDI and SMPTE ST 2110 both carry video over a network, but 2110 works uncompressed, with precise timing, for broadcast facilities. The SMPTE 2110 vs NDI comparison shows the differences.

Does i9TV work with SDI and IP?

Yes. i9TV designs and integrates SDI, IP and hybrid infrastructure, as part of broadcast systems integration.